Best Sellers

The perfect gift doesn’t exist...or does it? We hand-selected 12 of our best selling Olive Oils and Balsamic Vinegars that we think will tweak your curiosity. This inviting collection is an ideal way to try varieties that may be brand new to you, or ones that you have yet to order! Additionally, If you’ve been searching for a unique, thoughtful gift for the foodie in your life, this case of awesome most certainly fits the bill. Bonus points to us as we’ve made it easy for you - All these flavors are 5 star winners!

EVOO Flavors include: Basil, Blood Orange, Chipotle, Garlic, Meyer Lemon and Tuscan Herb

Balsamic Favors Include: Cranberry Pear, Fig, Sicilian Lemon, Neapolitan Herb, Peach and Traditional

We thoroughly enjoy collecting and assembling our best selling Olive Oils and Balsamics as we prepare our Exacta Gift Basket. Nestled in with the gleaming bottles is an exclusive, elegant Handmade Dipping Dish, gourmet Sea Salt, and 2 Self-Closing Pour Spouts. Beautifully wrapped and tied with a bow, the contents of this flat tray basket make it one of our most sought-after collections.  Choose from three delicious themed combinations that are sure to please your gift recipient. 

Three Different Combinations:

1.  The "Tuscan" Exacta Basket:  Tuscan Herb Olive Oil, Traditional Balsamic, Rosemary Sea Salt, Dipping Dish & 2 Pour Spouts.

2.  The "Garlic Lovers" Exacta Basket:  Garlic Olive Oil, Sicilian Lemon Balsamic, Garlic Medley Sea Salt, Dipping Dish  & 2 Pour Spouts. 

3.  The "Mediterranean" Exacta Basket:  Basil Olive Oil, Cranberry Pear Balsamic, French Provençal Sea Salt, Dipping Dish & 2 Pour Spouts.

From celebratory parties to housewarming gifts, we all scramble at times to find the perfect present to honor our friends, family, and work acquaintances. Our Daily Double Gift Basket includes our best selling 200ml pairing combinations of our popular Olive Oil and Balsamic Vinegars. Nestled on a reusable tray with two self-closing pour spouts, this popular basket choice is elegantly wrapped with festive ribbon and a handmade bow.  Truly a simple and beautiful presentation that is sure to please. 

Three Different Combinations:

1.  The "Tuscan" Daily Double:  Tuscan Herb Olive Oil & Traditional Balsamic & 2 Pour Spouts.

2.  The "Garlic Lovers" Daily Double:  Garlic Olive Oil & Sicilian Lemon Balsamic & 2 Pour Spouts.   

3.  The "Mediterranean" Daily Double:  Basil Olive Oil & Cranberry Pear Balsamic & 2 Pour Spouts.  

Ah yes, finding out that the perfect marriage of Olive Oil and Balsamic Vinegar does exist! We’ve paired some of our most beloved flavor combinations to bring you an excellent and easy gift for the foodie in your life! Keeping these for yourself? We really can’t blame you, especially since they arrive with a fantastic recipe to enjoy.

Please note: The Perfect Pairings do not come in a gift box.

We’ve tallied up the orders, calculated ticket sales, and kept tabs on our most popular Sea Salts. So, without further adieu, we present to you our Best Sellers Sampler Collection! Enjoy the timeless classic that is Rosemary with your next chicken entree. Rim your Bloody Mary tumbler this weekend with our Smoked Bacon, and enjoy the Garlic Medley on just about every vegetable you crave. All your favorites, one great group!

Ah yes, finding out that the perfect marriage of Olive Oil and Balsamic Vinegar does exist! We’ve paired some of our most beloved flavor combinations to bring you an excellent and easy gift for the foodie in your life! Keeping these for yourself? We really can’t blame you, especially since they arrive with a fantastic recipe to enjoy. 

Please note: The Perfect Pairings do not come in a gift box.

Whole, perfectly ripened blood oranges are crushed with Tunisian olives to make a beautiful Blood Orange Olive Oil that is fused with freshness and bright with flavor.

Barbara Braidwood, owner of Saratoga Olive Oil, loves using Blood Orange Olive Oil as a replacement for vegetable oil in baked goods.

The Portuguese Cobrançosa is lush and fruity with tropical fruit notes of ripe and green banana and macadamia nuts. A tingling radish spice that gently fades away to a clean and almost florally fragrant finish rounds out this best selling Extra Virgin Olive Oil.

Made by crushing and cold pressing the pulp from fresh lemons and olives together, this EVOO has a vigorous, zesty taste that you will not soon forget.

Reviving old recipes with fresh new flavors is as simple as picking up one of our Mini Bottle Pairings! You can also head over to our Recipe section to see which flavors would go best in your favorite dish, dessert, or cocktail!

Savor the fresh herb blend of oregano, basil, garlic, and rosemary as the infused, full-bodied merge of flavors elevate your next pasta, chicken, or vegetable dish!

Fay, our Fulfillment Manager, loves using Tuscan Herb Olive Oil for marinating and cooking chicken.

Produced at a small family farm in Vermont, this velvety sweet balsamic is made with 100% pure maple syrup! Unique and fantastic, it easily ranks as one of our best sellers!

Our best-selling Traditional Dark Balsamic is aged for 18 years in wooden barrels according to time-honored techniques, giving this ultra-versatile condiment an intense and complex flavor. It's the perfect balance of sweet and sour, with subtle notes of fig and caramel.

A culinary kitchen adventure awaits as you dive into this sweet, vibrant and versatile balsamic vinegar!

Go Fig or Go Home! As our best selling infused dark balsamic, our flavorful Fig is aged up to 18 years in wooden barrels and boasts a flavor so incredibly close to the actual fresh fig fruit.

This white balsamic is crisp, tart and perfectly captures classic holiday flavor. It's a year-round favorite with an amazingly fruity, complex taste that shines in a multitude of dishes – far beyond your Thanksgiving feast!

One of our top reviewed products. Never mince garlic again! Infuse your cooking with this all natural garlic olive oil.

Blair, our Sales Operations & Customer Service Manager, enjoys using Garlic Olive Oil when she makes roasted potatoes.

Being natural, vegetarian, and dairy free has never tasted so good. Smooth, silky, buttery goodness that tastes identical to the real thing!

The peppery bite of freshly picked basil melts with the creaminess of the cold pressed Koroneiki olives.

Zesty garlic, ground bell pepper, black pepper, onion, sugar, celery, and parsley join forces to bring you a unique sea salt blend destined to become your new counter buddy.  Sure to provide a memorable culinary experience, this amazingly bold and robust seasoning provides the perfect balance of garlic and sea salt.

Selecting one of our 60ml sample bottles is a wonderful way to try a new olive oil or balsamic vinegar.  Whether chosen for you or as a gift, these mini bottles are a splendid cooking treat!

Our Signature Bread Dip Seasoning is locally ground fresh right here in Saratoga Springs, NY!  This wonderful blend of herbs is made with a fragrant combination of roasted onion, rosemary, dried lemon peel, chives, oregano, parsley and a hint of sea salt.

Small: 0.4 oz | Large: 1.6 oz

Fun meets functional with these self-closing pour spouts! Expertly control the pour without having to worry about product rushing or dripping down the neck of the bottle again. Especially nice when entertaining, perfectly practical for everyday use.

Fun meets functional with these self-closing pour spouts! Expertly control the pour without having to worry about product rushing or dripping down the neck of the bottle again. Especially nice when entertaining, perfectly practical for everyday use.