Butter Olive Oil

The best substitute for butter! 

This creamy olive oil is all natural, vegetarian and dairy free. Tastes just the like the real thing.

$12.95
Pick A Variation

All Orders Shipped Within 24 Hours!



This creamy olive oil is all natural, vegetarian and dairy free. Use for sautéing or substitute anywhere you might use melted butter, including over hot popcorn, with seafood such as crab or shrimp, to dip bread in, over pasta, mashed potatoes, with rice or in baking. Add sea salt and you won’t believe it’s not butter!!!


All Saratoga Olive Oils are Kosher Certified.

Ingredients: Extra Virgin Olive Oil, Natural Flavors

Butter Olive Oil nutritional information

Chef Suggested Pairings

Vermont Maple Balsamic Vinegar

$12.95


Traditional 18-Year Balsamic Vinegar

$12.95


Cinnamon Pear Balsamic Vinegar

$12.95